QUESTIONS?
Should Kids Know What's in Your Will?
Our team is here to answer your questions and help you protect your legacy. If you’d like guidance tailored to your situation, schedule a time to talk with us.
Get StartedThe Big Question: To Share or Not to Share?
You've finished your will. You feel good about your decisions. Now comes the tricky part - should you tell your kids what's in it?
This question keeps many parents up at night, and it's more common than you might think. There's no universal right answer, but there are some solid guidelines to help you decide what works best for your unique family situation.
The decision often depends on factors like your children's ages, maturity levels, family dynamics, and the complexity of your estate planning arrangements.
Why Some Parents Choose to Share
Transparency has real benefits that extend far beyond just avoiding surprises. When kids know what to expect, it can prevent nasty conflicts and help maintain family relationships for generations.
Think about Sarah's family - she had three kids and owned a small business. She decided to leave the business to her daughter who'd been working there for years, while her sons would get other assets of equal value. By explaining this decision while she was alive, everyone understood the reasoning behind her choices. No hurt feelings. No family drama. No lengthy legal battles.
Here are the main reasons parents choose transparency:
- Prevents family fights: When everyone knows the plan, there are fewer surprises to argue about later, and siblings can maintain their relationships.
- Explains your reasoning: You can share why you made certain decisions while you're still around to discuss them and answer questions.
- Reduces anxiety: Adult children often worry about what will happen during difficult times, and knowing can bring genuine peace of mind.
- Allows for planning: Kids can make better financial decisions when they know what's coming their way.
- Shows you trust them: Sharing important information demonstrates confidence in their maturity and judgment.
- Facilitates smoother administration: Your chosen executor will have an easier time managing everything when family members understand the plan.
Why Some Parents Keep Things Private
Privacy has its advantages too, and sometimes keeping your will contents private actually protects everyone involved from unnecessary stress and conflict.
Maybe you have one child who's struggled with money management throughout their adult life. Or perhaps you're planning to leave different amounts to different kids based on their individual needs and circumstances. These situations can create significant tension if shared too early in the process.
Common reasons for keeping wills private include:
- Avoiding entitlement issues: Knowing about an inheritance might reduce motivation to work hard and build their own financial security.
- Preventing manipulation: Some adult children might pressure parents to change their plans in ways that aren't in the family's best interest.
- Protecting relationships: Unequal distributions can strain sibling relationships while you're still alive to witness the conflict.
- Maintaining flexibility: You might want to change your mind without having to explain every update to multiple family members.
- Avoiding hurt feelings: Some decisions might be hard for kids to understand or accept, especially complex financial arrangements.
- Protecting vulnerable family members: Information about inheritances might put certain family members at risk from others who might take advantage.
Finding the Middle Ground
You don't have to choose between complete transparency and total secrecy - many families find success with a thoughtful middle approach.
You might share general concepts without specific dollar amounts. For example, you could say "I plan to split things fairly among you three, but fair doesn't always mean exactly equal based on everyone's different circumstances." This approach prepares them without revealing every single detail of your financial situation.
Other effective middle-ground strategies include:
- Sharing your values and priorities rather than specific bequests and dollar amounts
- Discussing your executor choice and explaining why you picked that particular person
- Explaining where important documents are kept without revealing their contents
- Talking about your wishes for specific sentimental items that have family meaning
- Revealing information gradually as children mature and demonstrate financial responsibility
- Sharing your charitable giving plans while keeping family distributions private
Consider Your Family Dynamics
Your decision should fit your unique family situation because every family operates differently. What works perfectly for one family might create chaos in another.
Ask yourself these important questions:
- How do your children typically handle difficult or emotional conversations?
- Are there existing tensions between siblings that might be inflamed by inheritance discussions?
- Do your children have different financial needs or life circumstances?
- How mature are your children when it comes to money management and financial planning?
- Are you comfortable having detailed discussions about your estate and personal finances?
- Do any of your children have special needs that require different planning approaches?
When Transparency Usually Works Best
Some situations naturally call for more openness and benefit from family discussions:
- Your estate plan involves a family business that requires ongoing management
- You're asking one child to serve as executor and they need to understand their responsibilities
- Your children are all financially responsible adults who handle money well
- You have specific, logical reasons for unequal distributions that family members can understand
- Your family has a history of communicating well about difficult topics
- You've established trusts that will require ongoing family involvement
When Privacy Might Be Better
Other situations strongly suggest keeping things private, at least for now:
- Your children are young or haven't yet demonstrated financial maturity
- There's already significant conflict between family members that could get worse
- You're still uncertain about your final decisions and might make changes
- One or more children have substance abuse, gambling, or other issues that affect their judgment
- You worry about family members pressuring you to change your plans for their benefit
- Your estate involves complex business arrangements that would be difficult to explain
Age and Timing Considerations
The age of your children plays a crucial role. Teenagers might not be ready for detailed inheritance discussions.
Young adults in their twenties are still figuring out their careers and life paths. Knowing about a substantial inheritance might affect their motivation or life choices in ways you didn't intend.
Children in their thirties and forties often have more stable lives and can handle inheritance information more maturely. They might even benefit from knowing so they can plan their own finances accordingly, especially if they're dealing with their own estate planning decisions.
Special Circumstances Require Extra Thought
Blended families face unique challenges when deciding whether to share will contents. Step-children and biological children might have different expectations, and transparency might help or hurt depending on your specific situation.
If you're planning to set up an advance directive or make healthcare decisions, sharing some information becomes more important. Your children need to understand your wishes even if they don't know financial details.
Families with significant wealth face different considerations than those with modest estates. Substantial inheritances bring different responsibilities and potential problems that require careful handling.
Practical Tips for Either Approach
Whatever you decide, here's how to handle it effectively:
If you choose to share:
- Pick the right time and place for serious conversations - not during holidays or stressful periods
- Explain your reasoning clearly, not just your decisions, so family members understand your thought process
- Be prepared to answer questions and give family members time to process the information
- Consider having these discussions with an estate planning attorney present to provide neutral guidance
- Update everyone when you make significant changes to avoid confusion later
- Document these conversations so there's a record of what was discussed
If you choose privacy:
- At least tell someone trustworthy where your will and other important documents are located
- Make sure your executor knows their role and has access to necessary information
- Consider writing a detailed letter explaining your decisions to be read after your death
- Keep your will and other estate documents updated as your situation changes
- Tell your children you have estate planning documents even if you don't share specific details
- Ensure proper storage of all estate planning documents
You Can Change Your Mind
Remember, this isn't a permanent, unchangeable decision. You can start with privacy and gradually move toward transparency as your children mature and demonstrate better judgment.
Alternatively, you might share initially but decide to keep future changes private if family dynamics shift. The key is making a thoughtful choice based on your family's current situation and being willing to adapt as circumstances change.
What works perfectly for your neighbor's family might not work at all for yours, and that's completely normal.
Getting Professional Guidance
An experienced estate planning attorney can help you think through this decision carefully. They've seen how different approaches work out for different families over time, and they understand the long-term consequences of various choices.
Some attorneys even offer family meetings where everyone can ask questions in a neutral, professional setting. This can be especially helpful for complex estates, blended families, or situations where there are already existing tensions that need professional guidance to navigate successfully.
Professional guidance becomes even more important when dealing with business ownership, substantial assets, or complex trust arrangements.
The Bottom Line
There's absolutely no shame in keeping your will private if that's what works best for your family. There's also no shame in sharing it openly if transparency serves your family's needs better.
The right choice depends entirely on your unique family dynamics, your values, and your comfort level with these discussions. Focus on making sure you have a solid, comprehensive estate plan first - that's the foundation everything else builds on.
Then decide how much to share based on what will best serve your family's long-term harmony and wellbeing. Consider the personalities involved, the complexity of your estate, and the potential consequences of either transparency or privacy.
Whatever you ultimately choose, make sure someone trustworthy knows where to find your important documents when the time comes. That's not optional or negotiable - it's absolutely essential for your family's future security.
